Exploring the Debate Over Dutch Braids and Cultural Appropriation

Introduction

Cultural appropriation is defined as “the act of taking or using things from a culture that is not your own, especially without showing that you understand or respect this culture” (Oxford Languages, 2021). This definition has become increasingly relevant in recent years, as debates have arisen over the appropriateness of certain elements of other cultures being adopted by people who do not have any direct connection to that culture. One example of this is the Dutch braid, which has become popular in mainstream culture but has a deep history in African-American culture, leading to questions over whether it is appropriate for non-black people to wear them. In this article, we will explore the history of Dutch braids, the debate surrounding their use, and how they became a trend in popular culture.

Examining the History of Dutch Braids and Its Cultural Significance

The Dutch braid is a type of braided hairstyle that is similar to a French braid, but with an added layer of complexity. The Dutch braid involves crossing the strands of hair under one another instead of over, resulting in a more intricate design. While the exact origins of Dutch braids are unknown, some believe that the style was first developed in the Netherlands in the 1600s (Mondesir, 2017).

In terms of its cultural significance, Dutch braids have been a part of African-American culture for centuries. During the 19th century, enslaved women would braid their hair into intricate designs to express themselves and their heritage (Kershaw, 2020). Dutch braids were also popular among black women during the Harlem Renaissance in the early 20th century, when they were used to create a sense of solidarity and pride in the African-American community (Hairloom, 2019). To this day, Dutch braids remain a popular hairstyle in the African-American community.

Exploring the Debate Surrounding Dutch Braids and Cultural Appropriation

The debate over Dutch braids and cultural appropriation centers around the question of whether it is appropriate for non-black people to wear this hairstyle. On one hand, some argue that it is wrong for non-black people to appropriate a hairstyle with such strong cultural significance to the African-American community. As Dr. Yaba Blay, a professor at Drexel University, explains: “When we talk about cultural appropriation, it’s about taking something from a culture that is not your own and not understanding or respecting the power, symbolism and meaning behind it” (quoted in Kershaw, 2020).

On the other hand, there are those who argue that Dutch braids should be open to everyone, regardless of race or ethnicity. They point out that the hairstyle has become a popular fashion trend and that it should be seen as just that, rather than a form of cultural appropriation. As hairstylist Ursula Stephen explains, “I don’t think that people who wear Dutch braids are trying to take away from the culture. I think they just like the look” (quoted in Kershaw, 2020).

It is important to note that the debate over Dutch braids and cultural appropriation is not just about the hairstyle itself, but also about the impact it has on the African-American community. For many African-Americans, the Dutch braid is a symbol of pride and identity, and the fact that it has become so popular in mainstream culture can be seen as a form of erasure. As Dr. Blay explains, “When a style becomes popularized by non-Black people, it takes away from the Blackness of it, and makes it seem less special and unique” (quoted in Kershaw, 2020).

How Dutch Braids Became a Trend in Mainstream Culture

Dutch braids have become increasingly popular in mainstream culture in recent years, due in part to their frequent appearance in movies, TV shows, and music videos. The hairstyle has been worn by celebrities such as Beyoncé, Kim Kardashian, and Blake Lively, and it has become a staple of red carpet looks and runway shows. Furthermore, Dutch braids have become a common sight in advertising and social media, with brands such as L’Oréal and Garnier featuring them in their campaigns.

One of the reasons why Dutch braids have become so popular is because of their versatility. They can be worn in a variety of styles, from casual daytime looks to glamorous evening looks, and they are relatively easy to create. Furthermore, Dutch braids offer a way for people to express their creativity, as there are countless variations and combinations that can be created. All of these factors have contributed to Dutch braids becoming a trend in mainstream culture.

Analyzing the Cultural Appropriation of Dutch Braids Through Popular Media

While Dutch braids have become popular in mainstream culture, the way they are portrayed in popular media can be seen as a form of cultural appropriation. Many movies, TV shows, and music videos feature white actresses wearing Dutch braids, while black actresses are rarely seen with them. Additionally, Dutch braids are often used to portray a stereotypical “ethnic” look, which reinforces negative stereotypes about African-Americans. Furthermore, many advertisements and social media posts featuring Dutch braids fail to acknowledge their cultural significance to the African-American community.

These depictions of Dutch braids in popular media can have a damaging effect on the African-American community. Not only does it contribute to the erasure of their culture, but it also reinforces negative stereotypes about them. As Dr. Blay explains, “What we’re seeing in popular culture is a flattening of Black hairstyles, where they are presented as one-dimensional and without any historical or cultural context” (quoted in Kershaw, 2020).

Understanding the Reactions to Dutch Braids and Cultural Appropriation

The reactions to Dutch braids and cultural appropriation vary greatly depending on who you ask. Some view it as a form of cultural appropriation and feel that non-black people should not wear the hairstyle. Others argue that Dutch braids should be open to everyone, regardless of race or ethnicity. Still others take a more nuanced approach, acknowledging the problematic aspects of cultural appropriation but also recognizing the beauty and versatility of Dutch braids.

One way to address the issue of Dutch braids and cultural appropriation is to ensure that the hairstyle is properly represented in popular media. This means giving equal visibility to both black and non-black people wearing Dutch braids, and providing accurate information about their history and cultural significance. Additionally, it is important to recognize the fact that Dutch braids are a part of African-American culture, and to respect and appreciate the beauty of the hairstyle.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the debate over Dutch braids and cultural appropriation is complex and nuanced. On one hand, the hairstyle has deep cultural significance to the African-American community and its popularity in mainstream culture can be seen as a form of erasure. On the other hand, Dutch braids are a versatile and beautiful hairstyle that should be open to everyone. It is important to recognize the problematic aspects of cultural appropriation and to ensure that Dutch braids are properly represented in popular media. Only then can we begin to truly appreciate and respect the beauty of the Dutch braid.